
Dr. Levine is a gifted speaker and the co-author The Prevention of Eating Problems and Eating Disorders: Theory, Research, and Practice. He is the Samuel B. Cummings Jr. Professor of Psychology at Kenyon College and former chair of the Psychology Department. In addition, Dr. Levine received the Lori Irving Award for Eating Disorders Prevention and Awareness and the Meehan-Hartley Award for Leadership in Public Awareness and Advocacy. He is currently a Fellow of the Academy for Eating Disorders.
Last year, Dr. Levine provided us with an excellent presentation entitled “What are we waiting for?” The Necessity of Universal and Selective Approached to Preventing Disordered Eating. The feedback was so good, we brought him back this year to discuss, “Mass Media, Eating Disorders and the Bolder Model of Treatment, Prevention, and Advocacy. Dr. Levine joins us today to answer a few questions about eating disorder prevention, explain a little about what the Bolder Model of Treatment is and to explain the risks involved in a poorly constructed eating disorder prevention program.
Can eating disorders really be prevented? At what age is it best to begin implementing prevention efforts? The honest answer is that no one really knows yet whether eating disorders can be prevented, because long-term longitudinal studies have not yet been conducted. There is substantial evidence that some risk factors can be reduced — and some protective factors (such as media literacy) increased — over a one-to-two-year period. It is probably best to begin full-blown prevention efforts around the ages of 6 or 7. At this age, we can begin to promote eating a variety of foods (including fruits and vegetables), to facilitate an active life style, to promote multiple competences, and to reduce weight-and-shape-based discrimination and teasing.
What is the Bolder Model of treatment, prevention and advocacy? Where did it originate?
The “Boulder [Colorado] Model” of clinician-practitioner training, better known as the standard “scientist-practitioner model” informs current Ph.D. programs in Clinical and in Counseling Psychology. It was developed in the late 1940’s as the first Ph.D. programs in clinical psychology were being developed. The “Bolder” model of treatment, prevention, and advocacy was developed in the late 1990’s by the late Dr. Lori Irving and Michael Levine. It takes the feminist dictum that “the personal is the political” (and vice versa) and adds the professional element. An introduction to this approach may be found in:
Irving, L. (1999). A bolder model of prevention: Science, practice, and activism. In N. Piran, M. P. Levine, & C. Steiner-Adair (Eds.), Preventing eating disorders: A handbook of interventions and special challenges (pp. 63-83). Philadelphia: Taylor & Routledge.
What are the signs of an ineffective or detrimental prevention program?
Ineffective programs, some of which are potentially detrimental, tend to treat students as ignorant and easily led astray by culture. These unhelpful programs tend to lecture at students so as to provide them with frightening information that is designed to deter them from, for example, extreme dieting. These programs run the risk of being a waste of time, and, worse of being either voyeuristic (e.g., “look at the horrible, thin anorexic people”) or of inadvertently promoting unhealthy means of weight management. One prominent sign of an ineffective program is students who are disinterested because they do not see the issues as having anything to do with them.
Contrary to that, what major elements make up a successful approach to eating disorder prevention?
My review (Levine & Smolak, 2006) of every published and unpublished study that I could locate failed to reveal consistent elements in the successful programs. That said, I believe that the most successful programs have more (rather than less) of the 5 C’s: Consciousness-raising in regard to personal, social, and cultural influences on body image and eating; Connection-building, that is, fostering of relationships between students and between students and positive adult mentors; Competence-building, that is, the development of life skills such as stress management and assertive communication; and Change via Choice, such that participants in the program are encouraged to put their knowledge, connections, and competencies to work changing unhealthy personal, social, and cultural practices. The work toward these changes must reflect choices and other input that the participants provide.
Levine, M. P., & Smolak, L. (2006). The prevention of eating problems and eating disorders: Theory, research, and practice. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Many thanks to Michael Levine for giving us a glimpse into what is needed for a prevention program to be successful and at what point prevention can begin. This is such an important topic, as developing solid, valid prevention programs is the aim of so many professionals working in the eating disorder field. We look forward to hearing Michael share more about this topic on Saturday – April 18th at our annual symposium. If you have not yet registered, but would still like to come, you can register for this event, by visiting our Events Page.